Mısır Devrimini İçeriden Okumak

Bu yazı 24 Temmuz 2012 tarihinde Yeni Şafak‘ta yayınlanmıştır.

Mısır Devrimi’ne ‘içten bir bakış’ olarak değerlendireceğimiz Mısır Devrimi’nin Ayak Sesleri adlı eser Tarık Abdülcelil tarafından kaleme alındı. Yazarın kitapta yaptığı analizlere baktığımızda Mısır’da yeni ve daha meşru bir düzenin kurulması gerektiği tartışmasının aslında çok öncelerden beri yapıldığını anlıyoruz.

Mısır Devrimi’nin Ayak Sesleri, Tarık Abdülcelil’in 2008 ortalarından Mısır Devrimi’nin başarıya ulaştığı Şubat 2011’e kadarki dönemde kaleme aldığı yorumların derlenmesinden oluşuyor.

Continue reading Mısır Devrimini İçeriden Okumak

US-Turkey Relations: Arab Spring and the Search for Model Partnership

This article by Kadir Ustun and Kilic Kanat was published as part of SETA DC Perspective series in May 2012.

US-Turkey relations in 2011 were in stark contrast to the “troubled” year of 2010. Policy debates in 2010 focused on the political and diplomatic fallout from the Mavi Marmara incident and Turkey’s “No” vote against the UN Security Council resolution on Iran. Policymakers in Washington called into question Turkey’s foreign policy direction and the intentions of its leadership. Extrication of the Turkish-Israeli relationship from the US-Turkey relationship represented a structural change. As the two sides were seeking ways to adjust to the new reality, the historic transformations sweeping the Middle East in 2011 created a new dynamic in the bilateral relationship. Creation of a special personal rapport between President Obama and Prime Minister Erdoğan was critical for the leadership on both sides to recognize once again that their countries’ relationship needed strengthening. Notwithstanding the differences on a variety of issues, the move toward forging a “model partnership” has begun.

Download the Article (PDF)

Turkey Needs to Rethink Policy Toward Its Fractious Neighbors

This commentary was published by Al-Monitor on April 16, 2012.

When Turkey devised a policy of “zero problems” with its neighbors a decade ago, the decision was based on necessity, not necessarily on choice.

In the 1990s, Turkey considered virtually all its neighbors to be potential enemies who might support Kurdish militants of the PKK and its intention to carve out a separate state in Turkey’s southeast.

Turkey expended enormous financial and human resources trying to curb PKK activities both in Turkey and in neighboring countries including Lebanon, Syria and Iraq. The 90s proved to be a lost decade for Turkey, as the country could not move forward in spite of significant assets such as a young population and a strategic location. Continue reading Turkey Needs to Rethink Policy Toward Its Fractious Neighbors

The Syrian Quagmire: What’s Holding Turkey Back?

This article by Erol Cebeci and Kadir Ustun was published in Insight Turkey (Vol. 14 / No. 2 / 2012 pp. 13-21) 

The Assad regime has been playing all the diplomatic, political, and security cards it has accumulated over the past several decades. While keeping the violence under a certain threshold on a daily basis so as not to provoke immediate international action, the regime has benefited from the entangled and often conflicted international interests in Syria. The opposition has been unable to deal a serious blow to the regime and international pressure has so far yielded no major results. Though calls for international and regional action have recently intensified, there exists no clear international leadership or consensus on how to handle Syria. The Arab League and Turkey, along with other countries, have created the “Friends of Syria” group after the failure of the UN Security Council resolution on Syria, but Russian and Iranian backing for the Assad regime is seriously limiting options. Given its support for the people against authoritarian regimes during the Arab Spring and its anti- Assad stance, expectations for Turkey to “do something” are increasingly more pronounced. So, what’s holding Turkey back?

Download the Article (PDF)

Strategic Breadth and Depth: An Online Symposium on Turkish Foreign Policy

Reflecting on Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu’s exclusive interview with The Cairo Review of Global Affairsfive leading analysts discuss whether Ankara’s regional approach is meeting the challenges of a Middle East in transformation.

Steven A. Cook: Vintage Davutoğlu

Michael Wahid Hanna: An Ambitious Foreign Policy Vision

Leila Hilal: Turkey and the Syria Imbroglio

Marc Lynch: A Muddled, Reactive Approach to the Arab Revolutions

Kadir Ustun: Revolutions and the Question of Legitimacy

Continue reading Strategic Breadth and Depth: An Online Symposium on Turkish Foreign Policy

The Erdogan Effect: Turkey, Egypt and the Future of the Middle East

This article by Nuh Yılmaz and Kadir Üstün was published in the Fall 2011 issue of Cairo Review of Global Affairs.

Turkey’s foreign policy activism is drawing considerable attention these days, particularly because of the momentous transformation in the broader Middle East. The tour of Prime Minister Recip Tayyep Erdoğan to Egypt, Libya, and Tunisia in September underscored the rise of Turkey’s involvement in the region—and of Ankara’s potential to be a formidable and positive influence. Erdoğan articulated Turkey’s vision for a democratic Middle East. “The freedom message spreading from Tahrir Square has become a light of hope for all the oppressed through Tripoli, Damascus, and Sanaa,” he told an audience at the Cairo Opera House. “Governments have to get their legitimacy from the people’s will. This is the core of Turkey’s politics in the region.” Equally, Erdoğan’s tour demonstrated Turkey’s recognition of the regional shifts. He signaled that Israel will no longer be shielded from accountability by a strategic status quo that buffeted authoritarian Arab rulers like former President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt. Erdoğan’s message to Israel emphasized human rights, democracy, and the rule of law as the true parameters of regional balance of power. “Israel must respect human rights and act as a normal country and then it will be liberated from its isolation,” Erdoğan said. Continue reading The Erdogan Effect: Turkey, Egypt and the Future of the Middle East